The 7 Most Overrated Golf Courses I’ve Played: Don’t Waste Your Money!

Alright, let’s set the record straight right from the start: all golf is good golf. Seriously, you could drop me into any corner of the globe with a golf club in hand, and I’d be a happy camper. But that doesn’t mean every course is created equal, and some might just be a tad overrated.

Courses Can Be Good But Not Great

Now, don’t get it twisted. The courses I’m diving into today aren’t downright terrible. Many folks might rave about them, and who knows, you might even think they’re sublime! But for me, after a fair bit of hype and expectation, I came away feeling a bit “meh.” So stick around as I break down this list, share my two cents, and toss in some recommendations for alternatives that won’t leave your wallet feeling so light.

A Friendly Reminder

Just a heads-up: for these courses to make it onto the “overrated” list, they need some pretty serious accolades from reviewers and golfers alike. So, if you’re a die-hard fan of one of these spots, I totally get it. But here’s my take: prepare to be a bit challenged on your next golf trip!

7. The Pete Dye Course at French Lick

First up is The Pete Dye Course at French Lick. It’s often hailed as one of the top public courses in the U.S., but honestly? I found it a lot more gimmicky than other Dye designs. It’s got some wild elevation changes that might make you feel like you’re in a theme park rather than on a golf course. It’s tough, I’ll give it that—so much so that I fully recommend teeing off from the front boxes if you don’t want to be swallowed up by the layout.

If you’re cruising through Indiana, do yourself a favor and check out Sultan’s Run instead. It’s not just cheaper, but you’ll actually enjoy swinging your club instead of feeling like you’re training for a golfing triathlon.

6. Harbour Town

Next on the list is Harbour Town. Watching the pros navigate this course during the PGA Tour is a blast, but playing it? Not so much. Every hole is like running through a tunnel—narrow and unforgiving for your average golfer. And honestly, not many holes stand out as memorable; it all kind of blurs into one big yawn.

The price tag? Let’s just say dropping over $500 for a round here seems a bit excessive for such a flat experience. If you’re in Hilton Head and searching for a great alternative, give Atlantic Dunes a shot. Trust me, your scorecard (and wallet) will thank you.

5. Torrey Pines South

On to Torrey Pines South, which may be a local gem for residents, but for visitors? It’s just an okay course—pretty views along the cliffs, sure, but the design is kind of monotonous. There’s no personality to it; it feels like you’ve played this course a hundred times before.

If you happen to be hanging around San Diego, I’d say check out Encinitas Ranch for a more enjoyable experience rather than paying top dollar for something that’s just… fine.

4. TPC Harding Park

Let’s chat about TPC Harding Park. While it’s got that “fancy” factor with its prime San Francisco location and offers affordable golf for locals, I wouldn’t recommend it for visitors. Shelling out $250 feels steep for a course that has pretty standard holes running together without much to remember.

Instead, consider driving a bit to Pasatiempo. This course offers plenty of character and could very well deliver you a round worth remembering.

3. Champion Course at PGA National

Moving on to Champion Course at PGA National. It’s got PGA history, and yes, I loved watching the Honda Classic there back in the day. Unfortunately, the layout is littered with uninspired holes that seem more about real estate than good golf. The infamous Bear Trap holes may be memorable, but the rest? Not so much.

And let’s not even talk about the price. At around $475 a round, you’re better off exploring Palm Beach Par 3. You’ll get way more bang for your buck and some awesome golf memories.

2. Blue Monster at Doral

Now we’re talking about the Blue Monster at Doral. It’s just another spot that gets way more credit than it deserves. Sure, it’s pretty, and the conditions are top-notch, but you’ll find yourself spending $395, and for what? A long, demanding set of holes with almost zero creativity?

Instead, head over to Jacaranda Golf Club in Fort Lauderdale. You’ll find two solid courses that won’t make your wallet cry, and they’re way more fun than the Blue Monster’s monotonous layout.

1. TPC Scottsdale

And finally, TPC Scottsdale. I know many are shaking their heads at this one. It’s famous for the WM Phoenix Open, so I expected a lot, but honestly? What a letdown. The practice facilities and conditioning were impressive, and I had a solid caddie, but the front nine? Yawn city. Too tough for the average golfer, and honestly, once the grandstands are gone, the course just doesn’t have much magic.

For the price (about $400–$500 in season), consider skipping this one and heading to We-Ko-Pa instead. You’ll save some cash and find yourself on a course that truly rocks!

Let’s Hear Your Thoughts!

So there you have it—my rundown on the seven most overrated golf courses out there. Do you agree? Disagree? Think I missed a gem that deserves a shout-out? Hit me up in the comments. I’m always up for a good golf chat!

And remember, golf is about having a good time! Choose wisely where you tee it up, and let the good times roll.