The 7 Most Underrated Golf Courses I’ve Played

Hey there, fellow golf lovers! A little while back, I wrote about the golf courses that, in my humble opinion, didn’t quite live up to the hype. But after some of you reached out, I figured it was high time to shine a light on the other end of the spectrum: the most underrated golf courses I’ve played. Grab a drink, settle in, and let’s dive into these hidden gems that you might not have on your radar!

What Makes a Course Underrated?

So, what do I actually look for when I say a course is underrated? Well, it starts with recognition in the golfing community—or lack thereof. I’m talking about those tracks that maybe aren’t plastered all over Instagram but have their own quiet brilliance.

Another big factor? Price! It’s crucial to feel like you’re getting your money’s worth. Is the experience worth the greens fee? You better believe it matters!

And, of course, personal taste plays a role too. I enjoy courses that make you think, without punishing you too heavily if you miss the fairway. Give me intriguing greens and some playful slopes, where I won’t lose a bucket of balls but will still face an engaging challenge.

So, if you’re ready to explore some underrated treasures, here are seven courses that deserve a spot in your golf itinerary. Full disclosure: I’ve only listed public courses, and I’ve tried to cover different regions to offer a little something for everyone. Have some spots of your own to suggest? I’d love to hear them!

1. The Course at Sewanee (Sewanee, Tennessee)

First up, The Course at Sewanee—located just a stone’s throw from the more famous Sweeten’s Cove. Now, don’t get me wrong; Sweeten’s has its charm, but this little nine-hole wonder gets my vote for sheer simplicity and beauty.

Perched on a ridge, the views alone are worth the visit. And at just $55 to walk, it’s a steal! It might not have that cult status like Sweeten’s, but that’s what makes it easier to get a tee time. You can enjoy a more laid-back vibe without the hefty price tag.

2. Chaska Town Course (Chaska, Minnesota)

Next, let’s head up north to Chaska Town Course. If you were following last year’s U.S. Amateur, you might know that it co-hosted the event alongside Hazeltine. But make no mistake, this isn’t Hazeltine—it’s a different kind of animal.

The fairways are generous, stretching out to a not-too-daunting 6,800 yards. But don’t let that fool you; the course weaves in some tricky strategic choices, like the short par-4 fifth that has water lurking in the landing area.

Plus, for just $78, you can walk this beauty in the summer. It’s no wonder Chaska has become one of my favorite spots!

3. Park Mammoth (Park City, Kentucky)

Now, allow me to take you to Park Mammoth. This relatively new course opened up a couple of years ago, and it’s been a serious delight. Nestled in the rolling hills of western Kentucky, it’s not too far from Bowling Green.

I’ve played here multiple times and have always been impressed. The friendly staff, fantastic clubhouse, and excellent practice facilities make it worth your while. The layout is wide open, with fantastic greens. You’re unlikely to lose too many balls, but don’t let that fool you into thinking it’s a walk in the park; there are some serious challenges lurking around.

Best part? You can play unlimited golf on weekends for $137, and if you go a little earlier or later in the day, the rates drop even further. Win-win!

4. Duke University Golf Club (Durham, North Carolina)

Alright, let’s get real for a minute—I’m a North Carolina State grad, but I’ve gotta give credit where credit is due. Duke University Golf Club is beautiful. It’s a parkland layout that typically sees well-maintained conditions, especially since it just hosted the U.S. Open final qualifying.

While it may not boast the high-profile golf of the Sandhills like Pinehurst, it’s got a fantastic reputation among locals. The greens are quick and challenging yet fair. You might find the price a touch on the high side at around $170 max, but when you compare it to other courses in the area, it’s still a good deal.

5. Poppy Hills (Pebble Beach, California)

Everyone flocks to Monterey for the famed Pebble Beach and Spyglass Hill, but don’t sleep on Poppy Hills. Previously known as "Sloppy Hills," its renovations in 2014 breathed new life into the layout, revealing a course that rivals its coastal neighbors.

Now sure, Pebble and Spyglass might hold a place in the hearts of many, but Poppy Hills offers solid challenges and beautiful views, all while staying around $100 in summer. If you value good golf, you won’t want to skip this one!

6. Warren Course at Notre Dame (South Bend, Indiana)

Now, let’s talk about the Warren Course at Notre Dame. For years, this was my go-to answer for the most underrated course, and while it has gained some recognition after hosting the 2019 U.S. Senior Open, it still deserves a shoutout.

Famed architects Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw designed this course, turning an ordinary piece of land into something truly special. It’s a blend of challenges that won’t overwhelm you—perfect for a relaxed yet engaging round of golf. At max rates of $115, you’re getting a solid Midwest golf experience without breaking the bank.

7. Elie Golf House (Scotland)

Rounding out my list is the Elie Golf House in Scotland. Just a short drive from St. Andrews, this quirky links course will steal your heart. The first tee shot is particularly memorable—completely blind, you’ll be relying on a periscope to check that the fairway’s clear!

Elie offers a mix of par-4s and par-3s, along with stunning coastal views that’ll make you forget about your scorecard. Plus, with greens fees around $120, it’s a fantastic option for anyone looking to enjoy true links golf without the hype of nearby big names.

Wrapping It Up

And there you have it—seven underrated golf courses that are absolutely worth your time. If you haven’t played any of these beauties, consider adding them to your next golf trip. And don’t forget, I’m all ears for more suggestions. Which courses do you think deserve a shout-out? Let’s keep the conversation going in the comments! Happy golfing!