The recent trip to England with a group of Golfweek’s Best course raters has led to a demonstrable conclusion that English golf is superior, prompting the question of where the United States went wrong. The group played eight of Europe’s top courses in just six days, all of which offered a unique and eye-opening golfing experience. The bedrocks of golf in Great Britain and Ireland differ significantly from those in the United States, focusing on a quicker game played on foot, match play over stroke play, and a more inclusive and communal atmosphere.
One of the key takeaways from the trip was the walking culture among British and Irish golfers. Golfers predominantly walk the courses, with no buggies available except for medical needs, leading to a faster pace of play and healthier players who can continue playing well into their 80s and 90s. The community and camaraderie on the course is also emphasized, along with numerous caddie programs and courses designed for easy walkability.
Golfers in the UK typically play rounds in 3:30 or less, with many completing 18 holes in under three hours. This allows for more golf and free time, with most courses being easily walkable at 5,500-6,500 yards max. Additionally, players often engage in matches against their playing partners rather than focusing solely on stroke play, enhancing the social aspects of the game and improving the pace of play.
The focus on matches over stroke play also means that courses in the UK are not bound by traditional yardage and par norms. Many courses, including some of the best in the world, are under par 70 and less than 6,000 yards, allowing them to fit the land better and yield a better collection of holes. Furthermore, famous clubs often have “artisan” members who contribute in various ways, making the clubs feel more inclusive and community-oriented.
Maintenance practices at UK courses prioritize playable areas while eschewing unnecessary expenses on out-of-play areas. Non-golfers are often free to roam through the courses, adding to the community feel, and non-member access at private clubs is relatively easy to obtain. Clubs in the UK also offer lunch regularly rather than dinner, simplifying staffing and allowing for more efficient food-and-beverage operations.
Dog-friendly policies are common at UK courses, with furry friends often accompanying players on the course. This inclusion of dogs adds to the social interaction, reduces stress, and increases overall enjoyment for players. Ultimately, the lessons learned from golf in the United Kingdom point to a more communal and inclusive approach that could benefit the golfing community in the States, fostering a deeper sense of camaraderie and appreciation for the game.
