Golf’s Game Changer: The 2025 Most Wanted Mallet Putter Test

Hey there, fellow golf enthusiasts! Buckle up because PuttView has totally transformed the way MyGolfSpy conducts its putter testing, and the results of the 2025 Most Wanted Mallet Putter test have unveiled some eye-opening insights. With 36 mallet putters on the chopping block, over 180 hours of testing, and a staggering 23,040 putts tracked, this year’s lineup has been nothing short of mind-blowing.

Big dogs like PING, TaylorMade, and Odyssey strutted their stuff, but hold on to your hats because lesser-known brands like Wilson, Runner, and Makefield turned heads too. This isn’t just a wake-up call for golfers to think beyond the big names; it’s proof that the putter market is ripe for finding superb value and impressive performance from unexpected places.

So, what’s the buzz? Let’s dive into the winners, some surprises, and what all this means for you as you hunt for your next flatstick.

Key Highlights from the 2025 Test

Here’s a quick rundown of the top performers from the latest testing:

• Best Overall: Wilson Infinite Buckingham
• Runner-Up: Runner Mallet
• 3rd Place: PING Scottsdale Prime Tyne 4
• Best for Short Putts: Toura Proto P5
• Best for Medium Putts: Makefield Defiant
• Best for Long Putts: Stix Golf Compete Mallet

These aren’t just names; these putters earned their stripes by outperforming competitors in various putting distances, not by popularity or hefty price tags. The Wilson Infinite Buckingham took the crown by showing remarkable performance at medium distances, a key area for scoring.

What Makes a Great Mallet in 2025?

Mallet putters have always been celebrated for their forgiveness and stability. Fast forward to 2025, and we see that trend, now with a twist. Thanks to PuttView’s advanced tech, we not only know which putters are sinking the most putts but also how well they control distance, speed, and proximity to the hole. This stuff is crucial for every golfer aiming to up their game.

The Wilson Infinite Buckingham didn’t win just because it was decent across the board; it excelled specifically at medium distances—critical for separating the good from the great in scoring. In fact, it trailed just behind the Makefield Defiant in that category.

The Runner Mallet also made a splash, particularly on short and medium putts, proving solid across the board. If you’re more of a long-range golfer, the Stix Golf Compete Mallet really shined in that regard.

Tight Margins, Big Takeaways

Here’s something to think about: the competition among the mallet putters was so packed that the difference between the top and bottom performers was only 3.3 strokes. That’s way closer than we’ve seen in past blade putter tests. What this means for you? Choosing the perfect putter might boil down to fit, feel, and personal visuals, just as much as raw performance numbers.

The Top Mallets in Each Category

So, who really rocked it in their specialized categories? Check this out:

• Short Putts: Toura Proto P5 (-7.8 PuttView HCP)
• Medium Putts: Makefield Defiant (-9.7)
• Long Putts: Stix Golf Compete Mallet (-12.2)

But hold on! Not every specialized putter knocked it out of the park in every category. The Toura had some struggles on medium putts, while the Stix mallet didn’t perform well for short ones. That’s why it was the Wilson Infinite Buckingham that ultimately took the top spot—balance is key!

What the Forum Thinks

Let’s see what folks are talkin’ about. Forum members are buzzing with excitement over the unexpected showings from Wilson and Runner. Apparently, these brands are often overshadowed by giants like Scotty Cameron or TaylorMade. But opinions are shifting!

One user even chimed in with, “I rolled the Buckingham after seeing the stats—it feels super solid and rolls straight. Honestly shocked it’s not more popular.” Another fan remarked, “The Runner mallet isn’t winning any beauty contests, but if it keeps the ball online, I’m all in!” The takeaway? Ignore the logo and let the numbers guide you.

Subjective Appeal vs. Real Performance

Sure, champions like Odyssey and Scotty Cameron still have that “awesome” factor in terms of sound, feel, and looks. But in terms of actual performance, they didn’t quite rack up the numbers this time. Wilson and Runner may not score as high in the subjective categories, but they excelled at sinking putts and setting you up for makeable second attempts.

As one test critic aptly put it: “The prettiest putter won’t save you from three-putting.”

Final Thoughts

With performance margins tighter than ever and a newfound understanding through PuttView data, when you’re hunting for a mallet putter in 2025, focus on what fits your game. Do you need help with short putts? The Toura Proto P5 is your go-to. Seeking long-range control? The Stix Mallet has you covered. Want solid consistency without draining your wallet? Look no further than Wilson’s Infinite Buckingham.

Whether you’re in the market for a new weapon on the green or just want to keep your finger on the pulse of the latest gear, the MyGolfSpy Forum is the perfect spot for discussion. Dive into the conversation, share your experiences, and let us know: did the results of this year’s test surprise you?

Time to break out the flatstick and take your putting game to the next level!